Buy Bambalina 1.25 inch block heels with a memory foam insole. Sizes narrow 7-9, medium 5-13, wide 7-13, and wide-wide 7-13.
I ordered this taupe pump in a M width. I really like the way it looks. It feels a bit snug in the width so I may re-order in W. I didn't give it the full 5* because the "no slip sole" is not as thick as I was led to believe from the picture. The sole is imprinted with tracks; there is no rubber-like material. Non-slip soles are required for a woman my age. I haven't decided if I will keep this shoe.